NASHVILLE, Tenn. — Aftyn Behn has spent much of November benefiting from friendly national exposure on MS NOW, the rebranded MSNBC platform that has repeatedly showcased her message on affordability, rural healthcare and youth turnout. Her appearances on PoliticsNation, The Last Word and Weekend Primetime have largely followed the same pattern: wide latitude to discuss the issues her campaign emphasizes most, little pushback, and a presentation that reinforced her pitch to voters ahead of the December 2 special election.
That dynamic shifted this weekend.
During a live MS NOW Weekend Primetime interview, host Catherine Rampell pressed Behn about several tweets she wrote in 2020 during the nationwide protests over police violence. The tweets have since been deleted.
Rampell began the exchange by saying, “Representative, in 2020, you made some tweets that have since been deleted that were very critical of police. You said in those since deleted tweets that the Metropolitan Nashville Police Department should be dissolved. Another cheered on a teacher’s union saying that defund the police should be a requirement for schools reopening. And another saying, ‘Good morning, especially to the 54 percent of Americans that believe burning down a police station is justified.’ 2020 was obviously a very fraught year. Do you still stand by those comments? And if not, is there anything you want to clarify?”
Behn did not directly answer the question. “I’m not going to gauge in cable news talking points,” she said. “What I will say is that our communities need solutions. We need local people deciding, solving local problems with local solutions. And that’s not the overreach of a federal government or state government of what we are dealing with in Nashville and our cities across the state of Tennessee.”
Rampell followed up: “So you don’t want to clarify whether you still believe that the police should be defunded?”
Behn responded, “Once again, I don’t remember these tweets, but I’m—”
Rampell interjected: “I’m not asking if you remember. What is your position today? How’s that on this issue?”
Behn answered, “I mean, once again, I’m here to talk about my race, which is literally in nine days,” and returned to affordability concerns, noting that voters “can’t afford groceries,” that subsidies “are not going to be renewed,” and that cost-of-living issues remain the top concern across the district.
The exchange was a marked change from her recent MS NOW appearances, including her November 22 interview on PoliticsNation with Rev. Al Sharpton. That segment focused on economic strain, voter frustration and Democratic efforts to mobilize younger and working-class voters. Earlier MS NOW interviews similarly aligned with Behn’s central message and avoided topics her opponents have emphasized.
Rampell’s questioning broke that streak by confronting Behn with statements Republicans have highlighted for weeks. Her reluctance to clarify her present-day position on the tweets — despite multiple opportunities — created one of the first sustained moments of on-air difficulty for her in the final days of the race.
Republicans circulated the clip almost immediately, calling it evidence that Behn remains aligned with “defund the police” politics or broader left-wing activism. While the tweets themselves date back to 2020, the renewed attention centered on her refusal to address them directly when asked.
The exchange represented a sharp departure from the steady, message-aligned national coverage Behn had experienced throughout November. Rampell’s questions were factual, direct and rooted in Behn’s own past statements. The host’s style is policy-oriented rather than combative, which makes Behn’s evasiveness stand out more sharply. After weeks of message-aligned national interviews, this was the first time she appeared unprepared to defend or reinterpret part of her record.
The timing increases the significance. With three days of early voting remaining and the special election approaching on December 2, Behn is relying on strong turnout among younger voters and high margins in Davidson County to remain competitive in a district with a strong Republican lean. In a low-turnout special election, even brief moments of uncertainty can shape how voters view a candidate in the final days.
Whether the exchange alters voter behavior is uncertain. But it is the clearest example in the closing stretch of a national appearance working against Behn rather than for her — and it arrives at a critical moment in a race where small shifts in perception can matter.
Brandon Windsor is the Editor & Publisher of TNPOLITICO.
Discover more from TNPOLITICO
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
